House of the Hanged Man has moved!

If you are not redirected in 10 second, please click here.


Podcast reviews have moved to The New, New Podcast Review

2005-03-08

Microsoft's Anti-Spyware as an argument against Google's Auto-link

So far I've stayed out of the fray surrounding Google's Auto-link functionality. I can see both sides of the issue, and think that Dave Winer's comments (starting, I think, here) and Robert Scoble's comments (starting, I think, here) have some good points - especially when it comes to what Google could do to make the functionality of the toolbar a little less distasteful to content publishers.

It also doesn't help much that Google's not talking (in the blogosphere) about this. There's no "official" Google commentary about what their plans are for the toolbar and how they respond to the concerns brought up by bloggers. I know individuals have said things in other venues, but nothing really meaningful, and nothing direct to the users that I've seen (if you know otherwise, please, please let me know).

All of that said, I've found Cory Doctorow's comments, and those of Yoz Grahame and most recently Jason Kottke's to be more compelling (even though Yoz's are a little, um, sarcastic, in the "tearing of flesh" meaning). I further think that the slippery slope argument used by many of Google's detractors in this discussion borders on the fallacious.

Actually, I encountered the most compelling argument against the auto-link feature on my own computer this morning.

I had been in the habit of running both the free version of Lavasoft's Ad-Aware SE Personal and Spybot-S&D on a daily basis. Mostly they didn;t catch much, but every few days I'd get a tracking cookie hit or something of the like. That was until I installed Microsoft's Windows AntiSpyware. Then, somehow, they presence of that comforting window every morning telling me that Microsoft had run through the files on my machine while I was sleeping and hadn't found anything lulled me into a false sense of security and I hadn't been running my other spyware tools. This morning I opened up Spybot S&D to use a different tool int he package and ran the spyware check just for kicks. Guess what? It found a few things that Microsoft's tool hadn't found. I ran AdAware and found a few more.

Shocking you say?
Hardly.

In fact, the things these two tools found were tracking cookies, which I'm not even sure Microsoft's tool finds. The point of the whole experience is that somehow I had lulled myself into this sense of security based upon the activities of a less-trusted software vendor than Google. I'm a fairly sophisticated technology consumer, yet I allowed myself to be led down the garden path unwittingly. Other users are even more likely to trust the defaults of a tool released by a company that's got Google's reputation.

All of that said, I still come down on Google's side of this issue for these reasons:

  • The user has to download and install the tool, taking some responsibility for their actions
  • When the Toolbar Beta does its work on a page, the page is already on the user's machine, where they should have a lot of control over the page
  • The user has to click the button for every single page to have the auto-links display
  • The links are shown to be artificial in a way that many users will notice
  • Even setting aside the multiple Javascript code-snippets already available to disable auto-link, you can also disable it by creating the links you'd like to see there yourself.


So while I don't think the first step down the infamous slippery slope has been taken, yet, I do think we all need to watch out for it. If Google (or anyone else) does step across the line they our work to convince that company to turn back from the slope will be all the harder.

Update: Techdirt talks intelligently about the autolink slippery slope (an old post, but a new one to me).

12 Comments:

At 7:04 AM, Blogger tweedledeetweedledum said...

This blog is awesome! If you get a chance you may want to visit this mapping software site, it's pretty awesome too!

 
At 2:02 PM, Blogger Adele said...

Just thought id look in and see what you have here......feel free to check my ##KEYWORD## site, it might be of some interest...if u like ##KEYWORD## stuff.

 
At 11:43 PM, Blogger tweedledeetweedledum said...

This blog is awesome! If you get a chance you may want to visit this poker download site, it's pretty awesome too!

 
At 5:42 AM, Blogger swissred said...

I'm happy that so many people post info about adware on their blogs; I am the owner of an free adware download website; I'd glad if you pay me a visit. You'll probably find useful info for your next adware related posts.

 
At 6:57 AM, Blogger jobs123 said...

You have a nice blog here. Did you know
there Is A 90% Chance That Your Computer Has AdWare Or Spyware On It Right NOW!

Spyware and Adware viruses have rapidly become the number one threat to your computer with over 90% of computers already infected. These include trojans, bugs, ad serving software, monitoring software and more.
I also have a history of computer site-blog. It can help you find and get rid of spyware, adware plus other stuff pn your computer for good. Free downloads.
You should check it out if you get the time!

 
At 7:40 AM, Blogger swissred said...

I'm an adware expert, owner of a adware find search resource. I'm happy bloggers like you are starting to cover this hot topic. Feel free to get any info from my website for your blog!

 
At 6:26 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!
I have a free spyware downloads site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time :-)

 
At 3:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I must say that without some of the information you have, would my computer be filled with spyware. I'm always looking for more information about spyware yahoo and I have bookmarked your blog among the must visit resources!

Keep the good work up!
More info about spyware yahoo here.

 
At 11:23 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

One good resource for anti virus software and many more free software alternatives is Software4YourSuccess.com
Yes it is my site and I would love for you to drop by for a second. From there you will have free access to several of my products such as The Marketing Toolbar (which is goldmine of information on how to do things quickly and on the cheap, thus saving you time and money).
Also for webmasters I have created Webmaster Wizards, which will help you with almost every aspect of putting code on your site from things such as legal and privacy disclaimers to popunders. I have so much content and free software there I could fill up this whole blog, so check it out Thanks, Sincerely Rob Rudd

 
At 8:57 AM, Blogger Midnightrun said...

What an interesting Blog! But you're sure your system is clean of any Malware? At my keylogger related Site you can scan your Computer for free today!

 
At 8:21 PM, Blogger cc Infopage said...

Hello,

I am searching around for fresh information
for my cc Infopage, 30,000 daily updated Information Pages about all kind of subjects.

It might interest you to know that your blog has been visited and has been read. I hope you enjoy your "Blogging".

I wish you all the luck I can, keep the good work going!

Kind regards,
Jos
Today's News From & About eBay

Get the eBay Business Box Today

 
At 4:17 AM, Blogger doer said...

Hello, just visited your blog, it's informative. I also have a Eay related web site. Please visit and hope that it's useful.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home